Vacuum Test of Exodus-Like Capacitor Finds No Unexplained Thrust at Billionth-Newton Sensitivity
A highly sensitive vacuum experiment found no unexplained thrust from an asymmetric capacitor built around principles described in an Exodus Propulsion Technologies patent. In the 2024 Scientific Reports study, Martin Tajmar’s team applied 10,000 volts while using instruments capable of detecting forces measured in billionths of a newton.
The result is an important check on an extraordinary propulsion claim, but it is not a test of Exodus’s actual hardware. Tajmar, a professor and chair of space systems at Dresden University of Technology, did not know the company device’s exact dimensions. His experiment instead establishes the kind of sensitivity and artifact control an independent evaluation of the Exodus system would require.
Charles Buhler, an electrostatics specialist who helped establish a laboratory at NASA’s Kennedy Space Center, claimed in April 2024 that Exodus had built a device that produces thrust without expelling propellant. He attributed the reported effect to what he called a “New Force.” Exodus argues that its device exchanges momentum with the vacuum itself, while a company white paper says other experimenters have reproduced the effect. That paper does not include their laboratory reports.
Why vacuum alone is not enough
Capacitors operating at high voltage can appear to generate thrust for ordinary reasons. The most familiar is corona wind, in which an electrical discharge in air transfers momentum to surrounding molecules. Asymmetric electrodes can create a directional airflow that pushes the apparatus, even though the underlying mechanism depends on the atmosphere and cannot propel a spacecraft through empty space.
A vacuum chamber removes that major source of apparent thrust, but it does not eliminate every measurement problem. External power cables can exert small forces on a sensitive balance. Charged components can interact with the chamber or nearby structures. Electromagnetic coupling, slight shifts in the center of mass and movement caused by heating can also register as force when an instrument is resolving billionths of a newton.
Tajmar’s team placed the capacitor, battery and high-voltage equipment together on the balance. Keeping the power system aboard the measured assembly removed external electrical cables that could pull on the experiment or introduce electromagnetic interactions. The researchers also used shielding and operated in high vacuum.
At 10,000 volts, the capacitor produced no clear sign of an unexplained force within the experiment’s detection limits. Tajmar summarized the results bluntly: “It’s all negative.” The finding applies to the tested geometry and operating conditions, not every possible capacitor arrangement and not the proprietary Exodus device.
The controls an Exodus test would need
A convincing independent campaign would start with the company’s complete working hardware rather than a reconstruction from patent principles. Multiple laboratories would then need to reproduce the force using different balances or measurement methods. A result that appears on one instrument but disappears on another is more likely to reflect the test setup than new propulsion physics.
The experiment would also need an electrical dummy: a load that consumes comparable power and produces similar heat but is not expected to generate thrust. Comparing the claimed device with that control could help separate a real directional force from thermal drift, electromagnetic interference and structural movement.
Residual charge is another issue. Buhler has said the devices can continue producing thrust after power is switched off, but insulating materials can retain electrical charge after disconnection. The remaining electric field can continue interacting with nearby surfaces, so a delayed balance response cannot by itself identify a new force.
Polarity reversal, changes in device orientation and repeated measurements over heating and cooling cycles would provide further checks. Tajmar’s central recommendation is independent replication with different equipment and published results: You have to test it in an independent laboratory. And then with a different method.
Propellantless would not mean systemless
Even a confirmed force would be only the start of spacecraft engineering. The full propulsion package would still require an electrical power source, high-voltage hardware, insulation, controls and equipment to reject waste heat. Those components add mass and can reduce or erase an apparent advantage measured at the device level.
Physics already permits thrust without consuming material propellant: light carries momentum, so a laser produces photon thrust. The tradeoff is power. An estimated 100 million watts of downward-directed light would be needed to hold up a 1.2-ounce object using laser thrust. Any Exodus device would therefore need a measured thrust to power result before spacecraft designers could judge its practical value.
For now, the investigation ends at a clear experimental boundary. A comparable asymmetric capacitor produced no unexplained thrust in a sensitive vacuum test, while Exodus’s specific hardware remains untested by an independent laboratory. Testing that hardware with its power supply on the balance, a matched dummy load and confirmation by a second measurement method is the next result that could move the claim forward.
| More aerospace and engineering stories, right in your MSN feed. Follow AMI on MSN |
By David Whitaker — Associate editor for AMI’s aerospace and drone systems desk, translating flight systems, aircraft programs, spaceflight, and UAV developments into accessible technical stories.
